Rev. Mark Moeslein, CP 1917-1926
Rev. Joseph A John, SMA 1926 - 1928
Rev. E. H. Kramer 1928 - 1929
Rev. S.J. Kelly, SSJ 1929 - 1932
Rev. Thomas J. Foley, SSJ 1932 - 1935
Rev. Msgr. John F. Basso 1935 - 1947
Rev. Msgr. Adolph Marx, JCD 1947 - 1950
Rev. John M. Lundergren, CSSP 1950 - 1951
Rev. Francis J. Haas, CSSP 1951 - 1953
Rev. Charles J. Aubry 1953 -1969
Rev. Charles McNaboe 1969 - 1971
Rev. Jerome Caponi 1971 - 1974
Rev. Thomas Meany 1974 - 1977
Rev. William Bogart 1977 - 1980
Rev. Noel David 1980 - 1982
Rev. Claude Valentine, SJ 1982 - 1983
Rev. Joseph Doyle, SSJ 1983 - 1985
Rev. James Schappert, SSJ 1985 - 1987
Rev. Msgr. Robert E. Freeman 1987 - 1992
Rev. Msgr. Patrick Higgins 1994 - 2004
Rev. Hubert Hosanna 2004 - 2005
Rev. Anthony Mupala 2005 - 2010
Rev. Arularasu Mathias 2010 - 2013
Rev. Eualio "Yul" Ibay 2013 - 2015
Rev. Roy J Kalayil 2015 - Present